Reviewing mary ann glendon s new book, rights talk,1 ought to be easy for me. Mary ann glendon may be one of the most influential women in america that youve never heard of before. Mary ann glendon contends that the language of rights has so invaded the public scene that creative political discussion has become almost impossible. But the main drawback of rights talk is that it has crowded out other modes of political thought, debate, and even action. She has worked as a criminal defender, a civil rights attorney, and is the learned hand professor of law at harvard university. American rights talk is stark, simple, polarizing, legalistic, excessively bestowing the rights label harvards mary ann glendon provides one of those rare insights into why we are the way we are, exposing what is patently aberrant when externally viewed, axiomatic by force of habit, and an educational system catering to consumerism. Sound bite a sound bite is simply a clip from any audio that can be used to summarize, explain, or prove a point sound bites have become an important part of our government and they way messages are portrayed to our society. People may resort to rights talk at the expense of reasoned argument, preventing. Read rights talk the impoverishment of political discourse by mary ann glendon available from rakuten kobo.
Rights talk ebook by mary ann glendon rakuten kobo. Professor mary ann glendon is learned hand professor of law at harvard law school, and is a former united states ambassador to the vatican. Rights talk by mary ann glendon 3 editions first published in 1991 download daisy. Chapter one the land of rights in tocquevilles tenmonth study of america he found that the lawyers habits of mind ran down through the lowest ranks of citizens. The thesis of mary ann glendons book rights talk is a provocative one. A defense of rights talk according to the likes of legal scholar mary ann glendon, journalist george will, and general colin powell, rights talk has drawn americans into greater selfishness and atomism and devalued altruism, mutual concern, and assistance to one another pg.
Glendon writes frequently on scholarly matters of the law. She writes and teaches in the fields of human rights, comparative law, and political theory. First, americans tend to talk about rights as absolutes. This essay revisits mary ann glendon s comparative law study, abortion and divorce in western law and her subsequent book, rights talk. Epstein 2 american culture and american legal institutions have of late been. The focus of mary ann glendon s rights talk is observably to ridicule the mindset of the average american citizen and politician.
Glendon stresses the relationship between immoderate rights talk, the vast increase in litigation in recent decades and the weakening of democracy. She is antiabortion and writes forcefully against the expansion of abortion rights. Glendon s comparative study actually included a third topic. Rights talk, glendon argues, is seldom concerned with corresponding responsibilities or the general welfare. The impoverishment of political discourse and a great selection of related books, art and collectibles available now at. Eleanor roosevelt and the universal declaration of human rights. Never before have claims of individual rights of behavior and expression ben so absolute or so divine. Rights talk itself is relatively impervious to the other more complex languages we still speak in less public contexts, but it seeps into them, carrying the rights mentality into spheres of american society where a sense of personal responsibility and. An introduction to the study of the international protection of human rights, 2 nd edition. A copy that has been read, but remains in excellent condition.
The impoverishment of political discourse, a nation, and a world made new. Glendon points out how rights based claims have been powerless to turn. Legal historian lawrence friedman has said that modern america is a vast, diffuse. Almost three decades after mary ann glendon s rights talk, our political speech problem is worse than ever. The convergence of abortion regulation in germany and the. Glendon s acclaimed book traces the evolution of the strident language of rights in. Americans view the rights bearer as a lone, autonomous individual, rather than as an essentially social being inextricably related to family and community. I read across the political spectrum and glendon is conservative. Legal historian lawrence friedman has said that modern america is a vast, diffuse school of law. The impoverishment of political discourse by glendon, mary ann. Glendon has long been one of our most penetrating students of family law and one of our most enlightening students of comparative law. Mary ann glendon is the learned hand professor of law at harvard university, and a former u. Roosevelt and her colleagues as one that gives encouragement to those of us who want to believe, with the authors of the federalist papers, that human affairs need not.
Glendon shows that, in american society, both sides in political debates. Glendon notes that many americans, when asked what makes america and its freedoms special, respond with some version of the statement that you can do whatever you want at 8, 9. Here, harvard law school professor glendon argues eloquently and persuasively that modern american political discourse, by emphasizing an everexpanding catalogue of rights to the exclusion of duties and responsibilities, has lost the central role in civic life envisioned for it by the founding fathers. Her insightful explanation as to the perception of rights, its evolution, etc. Rights talk book by mary ann glendon official publisher page. A world made new by mary ann glendon 3 editions first published in 2001 download daisy.
Political speech in the united states is undergoing a crisis. Pages are intact and are not marred by notes or highlighting, but may contain a neat previous owner name. Harvard law professor mary ann glendon traces the evolution of this distinctively american dialect of rights talk since wwii and shows how it has reduced our political discourse to stark and simple terms. Professor glendon and i seem to share the view that all forms of moralityindividual, political. Glendon shows that, in american society, both sides in political debates frame issues in. The convergence of abortion regulation in germany and the united states. In these two lively, elegant, and lucid books, mary ann glendon. Not only is she a harvard law school professor and a leading lay voice in catholic affairs, shes recently been named to the presidents bioethics council. The impoverishment of political discourse, she presents examples of the talk behind laws and rights of citizens, and the actual actions. The impoverishment of political discourse, mary ann glendon, a professor of law at harvard university, gives those doubts systematic, thoughtful, and lucid expression.
951 955 884 428 662 1530 234 1512 572 38 728 297 534 1074 422 139 1333 949 1267 103 1236 228 1432 970 12 374 74 1246 1289 361 1594 852 350 1382 831 719 730 167 610 267 191 792 1494 590 1214